Key points

  • The Federal Constitutional Court amended its November 5 stay order to allow the Peshawar High Court to hear general Article 199 cases.
  • Cases concerning the imposition of governor's rule, a state of emergency, and 3-MPO remain excluded from the Peshawar High Court's jurisdiction.
  • The court bench clarified that a strict literal interpretation of Article 245 would otherwise bring the entire judicial system to a standstill.

According to ARY News and Geo News, the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) announced on Monday that the Peshawar High Court (PHC) may resume hearing general petitions filed under Article 199 of the Constitution. The clarification came during a hearing conducted by a two-member bench comprising Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq.

Key Details

During the proceedings, Barrister Gohar stated that the top court's previous November 5 stay order had disrupted proceedings at the Peshawar High Court and halted lawyers' professional activities, as reported by ARY News and Geo News. Justice Aamer Farooq observed that while a plain reading of Article 245 suggested that Article 199 cases could not be heard, such an interpretation would bring the entire judicial system to a standstill.

ARY News and Geo News reported that the FCC clarified its earlier order only suspended matters concerning the Maintenance of Public Order (3-MPO) Ordinance and the governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The court also approved an application from the Peshawar Bar Council to become a party to the proceedings.

Regarding detentions under Section 3 of the MPO, Barrister Gohar pointed out that a review board had not yet been constituted in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. In response, the KP advocate general informed the court that the review board would be established after three months, according to ARY News and Geo News. Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan noted that miscellaneous applications filed at the Peshawar registry would be examined once presented to the bench.

Context and Impact

The November 5 ruling by the FCC had previously restrained the Peshawar High Court from hearing constitutional petitions regarding the preventive detention of individuals under the MPO ordinance, following emergency measures in the province. Following that initial directive, the PHC administrative committee had suspended proceedings on petitions filed on or after October 12. The latest clarification restores the high court's authority over standard Article 199 matters while keeping emergency-related measures under the constitutional court's review.

Summary and What Next

The Federal Constitutional Court has adjourned further proceedings for an indefinite period following Monday's hearing. The Peshawar High Court may now proceed with general Article 199 petitions while matters pertaining to the state of emergency and governor's rule remain under the purview of the court, as reported by ARY News and Geo News.