Key points

  • The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) modified its directives to conditionally allow the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to hear preventive detention cases of PTI workers.
  • The PHC remains prohibited from entertaining pleas challenging the October 11 proclamation of emergency and governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
  • The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government submitted a report stating that the continued deployment of armed forces under Article 245 remains necessary.

According to Dawn, the Federal Constitutional Court on Monday modified its earlier directives, conditionally permitting the Peshawar High Court to hear cases concerning the preventive detention of PTI workers and activists under the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance (MPO). The development follows the imposition of emergency and governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, which had previously prompted judicial restrictions on high court proceedings.

Key Details

A two-member FCC bench, headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and including Justice Aamer Farooq, had initially barred the PHC on November 5 from hearing these matters, leading the high court to remove the relevant cases from its cause list, Dawn reported. Under the updated directives, the PHC may now take up the cases on the strict condition that it will not hear pleas challenging the October 11 proclamation of emergency and the imposition of governor’s rule in the province, where the army has been called in aid of civil power.

Prior to the initial suspension, the PHC had issued interim orders granting bail to detainees against surety bonds of Rs 100,000 each. The FCC has been seized with more than 60 appeals against these interim orders, which were moved by the additional chief secretary of the KP Home and Tribal Affairs Department, according to Dawn. The superior court had previously suspended PHC proceedings instituted under Article 199, citing clauses 3 and 4 of Article 245 of the Constitution, which restrict high court jurisdiction in areas where armed forces are acting in aid of civil power.

Context and Impact

During the proceedings, KP Advocate General Sanaullah Khan submitted a formal report as requested by the FCC, Dawn reported. The report maintained that the security apparatus has been operating under a unified civil-military stabilization framework following the proclamation of emergency to safeguard lives, property, and state installations. The provincial government argued that armed forces deployment under Article 245(3) and (4) led to the suspension of high court proceedings instituted on or after October 12, a measure described as necessary to shield executive security actions—such as MPO detentions—from premature judicial interference.

Furthermore, the KP government’s report stated that security assessments indicate threats, terrorist networks, and internal disturbances remain fluid, volatile, and interconnected across all districts of the province. Asserting that underlying security threats have not been sufficiently mitigated, the provincial administration maintained that continued military deployment remains indispensable and that it does not intend to withdraw or de-notify the armed forces, according to Dawn.

Summary and What Next

While the FCC has eased restrictions to allow the PHC to hear specific preventive detention matters, the limitation on challenging the emergency and governor's rule stays in place. The superior court previously indicated it could reconsider its suspension of proceedings after examining the provincial government's security report.