Key points

  • The Islamabad High Court directed the petitioner to submit documented proof of ownership for Bari Imam House to the CDA within five days.
  • The Capital Development Authority maintains the structure is an unauthorized encroachment on government land acquired in 1963.
  • Justice Ayaz Shaukat ruled that the court cannot resolve contested factual disputes regarding land titles without physical evidence.

A legal battle over a building situated near Islamabad’s most revered shrine has reached a critical turning point as the Islamabad High Court (IHC) demands proof of ownership for the "Bari Imam House." According to reports from Dawn and ARY News, Justice Ayaz Shaukat has given the property's caretaker a strict five-day deadline to produce documents or face the legal consequences of alleged encroachment. The ruling underscores the intensifying friction between administrative land acquisitions and structures claiming religious exemption in the capital's historic Nurpur Shahan area.

Key Details

The petition, filed by Muhammad Akmal, the caretaker of the premises located opposite the shrine of Bari Imam Sarkar, sought to challenge the sealing of the building by the Capital Development Authority (CDA). ARY News reported that the IHC disposed of the petition on Monday, instructing the applicant to establish both ownership and possession of the specific land numbers where the building stands.

During the proceedings, the CDA maintained a firm stance, asserting that the property is an illegal encroachment on government land. According to Dawn, the CDA argued that the land—comprising Khasras No. 435, 582, 591, 592, and 593—was acquired under a 1963 award for which compensation was already paid to original owners. The authority further stated that official records contain no mention of a structure named "Bari Imam House" on those specific plots.

In contrast, the petitioner claimed the site houses a mosque, a langar khana (community kitchen), and ablution facilities, asserting it is exempted shrine property. However, the IHC noted that the petitioner produced no ownership documents during the hearing. Dawn reported that the petitioner's counsel candidly conceded the property was not his client's personal land and that the relevant records were likely held by the CDA and the Islamabad Capital Territory administration.

Context and Impact

The dispute highlights a complex jurisdictional issue in Islamabad, where the CDA’s development mandates often overlap with lands traditionally associated with religious heritage. The CDA had previously sealed the premises on October 30 during a joint operation with the district administration. While an interim order on November 3 had briefly led to the de-sealing of the house, that order has now been merged into the final judgment, which places the burden of proof squarely on the caretaker.

The court observed that whether the structure stands on exempted shrine land or on land acquired by the state in the 1960s is a "contested question of fact." Justice Shaukat emphasized that such matters cannot be resolved through constitutional jurisdiction based on bare assertions alone. This case serves as a significant reminder that even structures with religious or community functions must adhere to the documented land-use laws of the capital.

Summary and What Next

The IHC has directed the petitioner to submit any ownership documents to the CDA within five days, after which the authority must grant him a hearing and review the evidence against its own records. According to ARY News, the CDA is required to issue a "speaking order"—a detailed written decision—within two days of that hearing. If the petitioner fails to provide the necessary documentation, the court has clarified that the CDA is at liberty to proceed with legal action in accordance with the law.