There is a contradiction within Pakistani society that I believe deserves a much deeper conversation.
We often criticize Western culture. We blame America for influencing our traditions, question India’s cultural impact on our society, and sometimes hold foreign countries responsible for changes taking place within Pakistan.
Yet, at the same time, we enthusiastically embrace their fashion, music, entertainment, and lifestyles.
So my question is simple:
If we disapprove of these societies so strongly, why are we so eager to adopt so much of their culture?
And perhaps an even more important question is: Who is actually responsible for bringing these influences into our everyday lives?
Let’s Start With Our Own Fashion Industry
Look at the direction of Pakistani fashion today.
Many clothing brands now sell outfits without including a dupatta. Something that was once commonly included as part of traditional Pakistani clothing is increasingly sold separately.
And the changes do not stop there.
Our own Pakistani designers showcase models wearing sleeveless outfits on their websites and in their advertising campaigns. In some cases, if a customer wants sleeves added to that very same outfit, she has to pay extra for the alteration.
Think about that for a moment.
We frequently hear arguments about how certain styles do not represent our traditional Pakistani culture. Yet our own designers are promoting these styles, and customers who prefer more traditional coverage may sometimes have to pay extra for it.
Even in bridal fashion advertising, we now see outfits designed and promoted with exposed midriffs and navels—styles that differ from the more covered silhouettes traditionally associated with much of Pakistani bridal fashion and reflect influences from other South Asian fashion traditions.
If we ourselves argue that these styles are not part of our traditional culture, why are our own brands and designers actively promoting them?
Let me make something very clear.
My concern is not about telling women what they should or should not wear.
What someone chooses to wear is a matter of personal preference.
My concern is about the contradiction in our collective thinking.
We speak passionately about protecting Pakistani culture, yet our own businesses, designers, advertisers, and consumers actively participate in changing it.
If we are adopting influences from other cultures, why are we so reluctant to acknowledge that?
Did another country force our clothing brands to create these designs? Did someone abroad instruct our advertisers to promote these trends?
No. These are also decisions being made by people within our own society.
So why do we immediately blame outsiders when our culture evolves in ways we claim to dislike?
We Enjoy Their Entertainment, Yet Criticize Their Societies
This contradiction extends far beyond fashion.
We watch Indian films, listen to Bollywood music, follow international celebrities, enjoy Western entertainment, and increasingly consume Korean dramas and music.
Sometimes I feel that young people living in Pakistan are more familiar with international music, actors, and entertainment trends than many Pakistani-origin children growing up abroad.
Of course, this is a personal observation, not a statistical conclusion.
But there is an interesting reason why this contrast may exist.
Many Pakistani parents raising children in Western countries make a conscious effort to preserve their cultural identity.
They encourage their children to speak Urdu, understand Pakistani traditions, appreciate their heritage, and maintain a connection with their roots.
Why?
Because they fear that growing up in another country may gradually distance their children from their cultural identity.
Having experienced growing up in America myself, I understand how important preserving that connection can be.
Meanwhile, within Pakistan, there can be a strong fascination with whatever is happening internationally.
Again, there is absolutely nothing wrong with enjoying another country’s music, films, or cultural traditions.
Cultural exchange is a natural part of human society.
The contradiction begins when we enjoy the contributions of other cultures while simultaneously promoting hostility or sweeping negative judgments about the very societies they come from.
Disagreeing with a country’s government or policies is one thing. Condemning an entire population or culture is something entirely different.
The Problem of Colorism
Another issue worth examining is the way we judge people based on skin color.
Within our own society, fair skin is often associated with beauty, desirability, and even social status.
People with darker complexions can face unfair comparisons, insensitive remarks, and discrimination.
These attitudes have complex historical roots, including colonial influences, class divisions, and longstanding local beauty standards.
But regardless of where these ideas originated, why do we continue to reinforce them?
Why do we make our own people feel inferior because of the color of their skin?
At what point do we stop pointing toward outside influences and acknowledge that we ourselves are responsible for perpetuating these prejudices?
Why Don’t We Adopt the Better Things?
If we are so willing to learn from other societies, why not also embrace some of their positive practices?
Why not place greater emphasis on civic responsibility, respect for workers, accountability, public discipline, and the dignity of every individual?
There are societies from which we can learn valuable lessons in these areas.
That does not mean Western countries are perfect. They are not.
Neither is Pakistan.
Every society has strengths and weaknesses.
But shouldn’t we be willing to recognize what others do well instead of focusing only on their shortcomings?
Appreciating another society’s achievements does not diminish our own identity.
In fact, the willingness to learn from others can make a society stronger.
The Responsibility We Keep Avoiding
Whenever something changes in Pakistan that we do not approve of, we often hear the same explanations.
“This is Western influence.”
“This is Indian culture.”
“This is what foreign media has done to our society.”
But I want to ask a different set of questions.
If these influences came from abroad, who welcomed them?
Who incorporated them into our homes?
Who turned them into profitable businesses?
Who promoted them through advertising?
And who made them part of our everyday lives?
We did.
Outside influences certainly exist, but we also make choices about which influences we embrace, reject, or adapt.
We cannot continuously blame other societies while refusing to acknowledge our own role in shaping the culture around us.
Perhaps one of our greatest challenges is our reluctance to accept responsibility.
We are often quick to identify the shortcomings of others, yet hesitant to confront our own.
There is nothing wrong with loving Pakistan, valuing our traditions, or protecting our cultural identity.
But loving our culture should never require us to hate someone else’s.
We should be able to appreciate the good in other societies without feeling that our own identity is under threat.
Cultural pride and respect for others can coexist.
And I want to leave readers with one final question:
If we continue blaming the outside world for every change taking place within our own society, who will take responsibility for making our society better?
